Surprising cover songs reveal more about singers than their own hits

A singer’s choice of covers, karaoke songs and childhood favourites often shows their influences more clearly than their own hits do. A Guardian.

A singer’s choice of covers, karaoke songs and childhood favourites often shows their influences more clearly than their own hits do. A Guardian interview with the singer from Texas, built around a hard-rock cover nobody expects from her, is a useful example.

Key takeaways

  • The “honest playlist” interview format asks musicians to name the songs that shaped them, which can reveal influences their own records do not show.
  • The Guardian reports that the Texas singer first fell for music through a family record player and Nancy Sinatra’s These Boots Are Made for Walkin’.
  • A cover from a distant genre, such as a pop vocalist singing AC/DC’s Highway to Hell, can surprise listeners precisely because it shows tastes outside the artist’s public image.
  • These playlists are chosen and presented by the artists themselves, so they are evidence of how musicians want to be understood as well as of what actually influenced them.

The argument: what a singer covers shows what shaped them

An artist’s own catalogue is shaped by many forces besides personal taste. Producers, co-writers, record labels, radio formats and the commercial pressure to repeat a successful sound all affect what gets released under a performer’s name. A run of hit singles can therefore give a narrow picture of what the person actually listens to, admires or grew up with.

Cover versions, karaoke choices and childhood favourites face fewer of those filters. Nobody chooses a karaoke song for its chart potential. A cover performed live, especially one far from the artist’s usual genre, is usually picked because the singer enjoys it or wants to show a side of themselves the audience has not seen. The earliest records someone loved were usually chosen by circumstance, by whatever was in the house, not by the market.

Taken together, these choices form a second, unofficial portrait of a musician. This article argues that this portrait is often a more honest guide to an artist’s influences than their best-known recordings. The interview format the Guardian uses, which asks musicians to go through their personal musical history song by song, is built to bring that portrait out.

The Guardian’s interview with the Texas singer is a clear case. The headline is not about any of her own songs. It is about a hard-rock cover that, by her own account, catches people off guard. The interview also traces her musical identity back to a children’s bedroom and a pile of second-hand albums, not to the band’s catalogue.

Evidence one: the records that happen to be in the house

The Guardian reports that the singer’s mother gave her an old Dansette record player and a stack of albums when she was about eight to ten years old. She listened with her younger sister, Corinne, and the song that gave her butterflies was Nancy Sinatra’s These Boots Are Made for Walkin’.

That kind of origin story is common among musicians, and it matters because it is mostly accidental. A child with a hand-me-down record player and a parent’s albums does not pick from the whole history of recorded music. They hear what happens to be there. Their first musical attachments are inherited, not curated, and those attachments can last long after the artist has started writing and recording in a very different style.

The singer links the song to something she still sees in herself. According to the Guardian, she later read that Sinatra had been told to perform the track with a more provocative attitude, and she says the sass and strength are audible in the recording. She suggests this may be where her own uncompromising attitude came from, describing it with a phrase too strong to repeat in full here.

The point is not whether that link can be proved. It cannot. What matters is that the singer traces part of her stage persona to a song in a different genre and era, heard through a domestic record player, rather than to anything on her own records. Someone who knew only her band’s hits would have no reason to connect her to that record. The influence shows up only when she is asked about her listening history directly.

The Dansette detail adds to this. Portable record players of that kind were a familiar part of British households for a generation, and their place in a family home meant children often met music through their parents’ collections. In that setting, the line between a parent’s taste and a child’s first loves is blurred. That blurring is the kind of formative influence an artist’s own discography rarely shows.

Evidence two: karaoke as unguarded repertoire

The interview also asks which song the singer would choose at karaoke. The Guardian reports that she would happily take on any Marvin Gaye song, naming You’re All I Need to Get By as an example. The source text breaks off at that point, so the rest of her answer is not known here.

Karaoke is useful evidence because it is low-stakes. There is no record deal, no radio playlist and no critical reception to think about. A singer choosing a karaoke song is choosing something they enjoy singing, often something that fits their voice comfortably or that they have loved for a long time. The choice tells you about the music that sits easily in their body and memory.

Picking classic soul says something about the singer’s vocal tastes that may not be obvious from her own band’s records. Vocal phrasing, warmth and a feel for rhythm and blues are things a singer can absorb from records they love and carry into their own work without the debt ever being clear to listeners. A karaoke answer can make that debt visible.

This is the general value of the karaoke question in interviews of this kind. It moves the conversation from what the artist produces to what the artist likes to inhabit. The two overlap, but they are not the same, and the gap between them is where the more personal portrait sits.

Evidence three: the cover that throws people

The headline of the Guardian piece quotes the singer saying she does a very good version of AC/DC’s Highway to Hell, and that it throws people. The source material does not say in what setting she performs it, how often, or how audiences have reacted beyond being surprised. Those details are not known here.

Even so, the remark shows something about how cover versions work. A cover from inside an artist’s own genre tends to confirm what the audience already thinks. A cover from a distant genre, here a pop and rock vocalist taking on a hard-rock anthem, breaks that expectation. The surprise comes from a mismatch between the public image and the song, and that mismatch is informative. It tells the audience the singer’s tastes and abilities go beyond what they had assumed.

Artists often use cross-genre covers for exactly this reason. Doing one is a way of saying that the official catalogue is not the whole story. Because covers come with few commercial expectations, especially in live settings, they are one of the few places a well-known performer can show a side that their own singles do not.

The singer’s own phrasing, that the cover “throws” people, shows she knows about this gap and enjoys it. A cover chosen to surprise is still a deliberate act of self-presentation. It is also a sign of real enthusiasm, because nobody keeps a demanding rock song in their repertoire unless they like singing it.

The case against: playlists are performances too

The strongest objection is that these playlist interviews are not neutral evidence at all. They are conversations with a journalist, published by a newspaper, about a public figure who has every reason to present herself in a particular way. A musician asked to name life-changing songs is building a narrative. The choices may be sincere, but they are also selected, ordered and phrased with an audience in mind.

Memory is another problem. Accounts of childhood listening are recalled decades later and shaped by everything that has happened since. When a singer links her adult attitude to a song heard as a child, she is offering an interpretation, not a documented cause. It is equally possible that she came to value the song because it fitted a persona that developed for other reasons.

There is also a case that an artist’s own recordings are the more honest evidence, not the less honest. Hits reflect years of work, songwriting decisions and repeated choices about sound and style. Even with commercial pressure involved, a body of released work is what the artist actually spent their working life making. A single surprising cover, or one karaoke preference, is thin evidence by comparison. A rock cover might be a party piece and nothing more.

Finally, a surprising cover gets noticed because it is surprising. That novelty can exaggerate its importance. A headline built around an unexpected AC/DC cover may tell readers more about what makes an interview shareable than about what really shaped the singer’s music.

These objections are serious. They suggest the playlist format is best read as one source among several, a self-portrait to set beside the official catalogue, not a replacement for it.

What would change the conclusion

The argument here rests on a few interviews, anecdotes and remarks. Firmer evidence could strengthen or weaken it.

If artists’ live setlists over long periods showed that cross-genre covers were rare, short-lived novelties, that would suggest such covers are a minor part of a performer’s musical identity. If they showed the same unexpected covers coming back year after year, that would support the view that they reflect lasting tastes.

Comparing what artists say about their influences with what musicologists can actually hear in their recordings would also help. If the influences artists claim in playlist interviews regularly showed up in phrasing, arrangement or vocal technique, the format would look reliable. If claimed influences and audible ones often diverged, the format would look closer to self-mythology.

Accounts from collaborators, producers and bandmates would be a third check. If people who worked closely with an artist described the same formative records, the artist’s own account would carry more weight. If their accounts differed, it would suggest the public playlist is partly a constructed story.

None of this evidence is in the material covered here. Until it is gathered, the claim that covers and childhood favourites reveal more than hits is a reasonable reading of interviews, not a settled finding.

Sources and further reading

  • The Guardian, music section: the “honest playlist” interview with the Texas singer, which is the main source for the details about her listening history reported here.
  • Music journalism archives: the wider tradition of interviews in which artists list their formative and favourite songs.
  • Musicology and popular music studies: academic work on cover versions, genre and how performers present their identity.
  • Histories of British domestic audio: background on portable record players and family listening in the post-war home.

Surfaced from the rss:guardian_music signal “a singer’s personal playlist”. AI-assisted draft, editorially reviewed.

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today
share this recipe:
Facebook
X
WhatsApp
Telegram
Email
Reddit