Amazon’s in-app campaign against New York’s Delivery Protection Act

Amazon is using push notifications and home-page banners to warn some New York City shoppers that a proposed city bill, the Delivery Protection Act.

Amazon is using push notifications and home-page banners to warn some New York City shoppers that a proposed city bill, the Delivery Protection Act, could add up to $5 to each order. The bill is backed by the city’s mayor and by labour groups.

The bill and the campaign

The Delivery Protection Act is proposed legislation in New York City. According to The Verge, it has the support of the city’s mayor and of several labour organisations, including the Teamsters union. The Verge’s summary says the bill would require Amazon to change parts of how it handles deliveries in the city. That summary is cut off before it lists the obligations, so the exact provisions are not known here and are not described in this article.

Amazon’s response is the part that has drawn attention. The Verge reports that the company is sending push notifications to some users and showing banners on its home page. These messages warn that the bill could add as much as $5 per order for New York City customers. In practice, a retailer is using its own shopping app to speak to its customers about a political question. Those customers are also voters, and the company is taking a side.

This tactic is sometimes called in-app advocacy or platform lobbying. A company with millions of active users turns its product into a channel for a policy message, usually without going through the advertising or media outlets that political campaigns normally pay for.

Origins of platform lobbying

Companies have lobbied governments for as long as governments have regulated companies. The new element is how close the message gets to the customer. Traditional corporate lobbying happens through trade associations, meetings with officials, campaign donations and paid advertising. Apps let a company put a message on a customer’s lock screen or on the first page they see when they open the service.

Ride-hailing companies were early examples of this approach. In 2015, Uber added a feature to its New York app to protest a proposed cap on the number of ride-hail vehicles in the city. The feature showed users what longer waiting times might look like if the cap passed. In California in 2020, app-based ride-hail and delivery companies backed Proposition 22, a ballot measure on whether their drivers should be treated as independent contractors. They used in-app messages to reach both customers and drivers. Since then, short-term rental and food-delivery platforms in several cities have used similar methods when facing local regulation.

All of these cases follow the same pattern. A city or state proposes rules affecting a platform’s costs or its relationship with workers. The platform then tells users directly that the rules will make the service worse or more expensive. Amazon’s notifications in New York follow this pattern, and they come from one of the largest delivery operations in the city.

How the messaging works today

Push notifications and home-page banners are among the most visible spaces a consumer app has. Companies normally use them for order updates, discounts and product promotions. When they carry a policy message instead, the message reaches people who did not go looking for political information and who may not follow local politics closely.

The Verge reports that Amazon’s messages focus on cost, with the figure of up to $5 per order. Framing a complex regulation as a single price is common in these campaigns, because the claim is concrete and easy to remember. The Verge’s material does not explain how the $5 figure was calculated, whether any independent body has checked it, or whether the company says it would pass the full amount on to customers. Those points are not known from the source.

The Verge also reports that the messages are going to some users, not all. It is not known how Amazon chooses which customers see them, how many people have received them, or whether the messages ask recipients to take a specific action such as contacting elected officials.

Supporters of the bill, including the labour groups The Verge names, are likely to describe it in terms of worker conditions, safety or accountability, not consumer prices. The provisions they support are not detailed in the source, so this article cannot assess their arguments or the company’s.

Common misconceptions

One common mistake is to read the $5 figure as a fixed fee or a tax set by the bill. As The Verge reports it, the figure is Amazon’s own warning about what the bill could add, and it is described as an upper limit. Nothing in the source shows that the legislation itself sets a charge per order.

A second mistake is to assume the bill has already passed. The Verge describes it as a new bill. It does not say whether it has been voted on, amended or scheduled for a hearing. In New York City, local laws are normally passed by the City Council, so the bill’s status depends on the Council’s process, which the source does not describe.

A third mistake is to treat in-app advocacy as unusual or necessarily improper. Companies are generally allowed to state their views on legislation, and as the cases above show, platforms have done so before. The debate is usually about disclosure, accuracy and scale. Critics argue that a company’s direct access to customers gives it an outsized voice. Companies argue that customers deserve to know about changes that could affect them.

Finally, some readers may assume the bill applies only to Amazon. The Verge’s summary refers to requirements on Amazon, but the source does not say whether other delivery companies would also be covered.

Where to look next

The most reliable record of the bill is the official text and legislative history held by the New York City Council. That record usually includes the sponsors, committee referrals, hearing dates and any amended versions. Committee hearing testimony often shows the arguments on each side in more detail than public campaigns do.

Statements from the labour groups backing the bill, including the Teamsters, should explain what problems the bill is meant to address. Amazon’s public policy communications may explain how it calculated its cost estimate. Any independent fiscal or economic analysis, if one is published, would help readers judge the $5 claim.

For background on the wider practice, coverage of the 2020 Proposition 22 campaign in California and of earlier ride-hail disputes in New York shows how these campaigns have played out before. Academic work on platform power and corporate political activity puts them in a broader context.

Frequently asked questions

What is New York City’s Delivery Protection Act?

The Delivery Protection Act is a proposed New York City bill which, according to The Verge, is backed by the city’s mayor and labour groups including the Teamsters. The Verge reports that it would place requirements on Amazon’s delivery operations. The full list of provisions is not given in the material available here, so the bill text on the City Council’s record is the best place to find the detail.

Why is Amazon sending notifications about a city bill?

The Verge reports that Amazon is using push notifications and home-page banners to warn some New York City shoppers that the bill could add up to $5 per order. Platforms have used this kind of direct messaging before to rally customers against regulation, most notably in ride-hailing disputes. Amazon’s own stated reasons are not set out in the source.

Will the bill really add $5 to every Amazon order?

Not necessarily. The $5 figure comes from Amazon’s own messaging and, as reported by The Verge, is presented as an upper limit (“up to $5”), not a fixed charge. The source does not explain how the estimate was calculated or whether it has been independently checked. Nothing reported indicates that the bill itself sets a fee per order.

Has the Delivery Protection Act been passed?

The Verge describes it as a new bill, and the available reporting does not say it has been passed. Local laws in New York City normally go through the City Council, which involves committee consideration and a vote. Readers wanting the current status should check the Council’s official legislative records, which list hearings, amendments and votes.

Is it legal for companies to lobby customers through their apps?

Companies are generally allowed to express views on proposed legislation, and app-based platforms have done so openly in previous campaigns, including California’s Proposition 22 in 2020. Specific rules on political communication, disclosure and lobbying registration vary by jurisdiction. Whether any particular rule applies to Amazon’s New York messages is not addressed in the available reporting.

Sources and further reading

  • The Verge: reporting on Amazon’s push notifications and banners opposing the Delivery Protection Act
  • New York City Council: official legislative records, bill texts and committee hearing materials
  • International Brotherhood of Teamsters: public statements from one of the labour groups backing the bill
  • Coverage and analysis of California’s 2020 Proposition 22 campaign: background on in-app advocacy by platform companies

Surfaced from the rss:verge signal “retailer lobbying via app alerts”. AI-assisted draft, editorially reviewed.

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today
share this recipe:
Facebook
X
WhatsApp
Telegram
Email
Reddit